Small merchants using Magento. Everyone has an opinion, and they’re not all favourable.
Of the 200,000+ online stores that use Magento, a lot of these are smaller merchants.
I’ve witnessed small merchants be pitied or belittled for choosing Magento.
Sure, many would argue that small merchants are better suited to using Shopify, Zoey, BigCommerce or another out-of-the-box e-commerce platform marketed at small e-commerce stores (I hear your cries as I write this). That Magento is too complex for the average small merchant with little to no technical knowledge or training. That the promise of a free and powerfully customisable open-source platform is an empty one unless it’s matched by the resources to invest in getting it right. Do small merchants need the customisation power of Magento at this stage of their e-commerce journey? Maybe. Maybe not. It really depends.
But these merchants have done their research and have chosen Magento for a variety of reasons - whether it’s the customisation and enhancement potential, the promise of owning their own patch of e-commerce real estate under their control, or even the perceived ‘free’ price-tag. From their perspective, Magento aligns with their business goals.
I’m writing this blog to make two arguments:
Unless we’ve been hired to advise merchants on platform choice, as Magento developers we should respect the choice of small merchants to use Magento. As a Magento extension provider, it’s not my place to tell merchants which e-commerce platform they should select for their business. My role is to support merchants with the solutions they need once they’ve made the decision to build on Magento.
- I believe that small merchants, while often overlooked, play an important role in the Magento ecosystem. This topic is dear to my heart because like small merchants, most extension providers are also relatively small players. And our connection, although rarely acknowledged, offers huge value and is felt throughout the Magento community.
Let’s drill in deeper.
Who’s Who In The Magento Community
Before we get started, it’s helpful to do a quick review of the main players in the Magento world and understand how their role affects the broader Magento ecosystem. Here’s my view of how the various players interact (our friends at WebShopApps also offer an interesting breakdown):
Merchants: People who use the Magento platform to sell products. These include large multi-national players like Coca Cola running Magento Enterprise, all the way through to the smaller ‘mom and pop‘ merchants using the Community Edition. They are at the heart of everything we do and their success is ultimately what should drive the rest of the ecosystem.
Magento: The creators and stewards of our beloved Magento platform. They release the platform, promote it, and release periodic updates
Technology Partners: Developers who offer ‘out-of-the-box’ solutions like extensions or integrations to solve a specific problem, and avoid the need to hire developers to develop custom functionality. Solutions are one piece of the overall puzzle - they contribute one component towards the overall function or appearance of a Magento website
- Solution Providers: Individual developers and digital agencies who build and run a website on behalf of their clients, typically providing an end-to-end e-commerce solution
What’s the importance of small merchants to these players?
Small Merchants Help to Make Magento Better for Everyone
The majority of Magento’s resources go towards selling, supporting and improving Magento Enterprise. So it’s only logical that Magento receives most of their feedback on the Magento platform and its future direction from paying Enterprise customers and the Solution Providers (mainly paying partners) that enable those merchants.
This focus on Enterprise level business is necessary to generate the revenue needed to support and grow the Magento platform. It’s perfectly understandable that Magento’s strategy is to focus on their highest revenue customers and support their success with Magento. I’m not trying to argue against it.
But somewhere in this focus on big players, I can’t help but feel there’s a missed opportunity to gather real, grassroots feedback from the many thousands of smaller merchants who use Magento.
Small merchants tend to do most things themselves - many don’t have the budget to hire a Magento developer (I suppose this lack of spending power is the main reason they’re often seen as unimportant). They’re at the forefront of their e-commerce business - this means putting the Magento platform through its paces and making sure it works as intended.
This means that small merchants kick butt at finding bugs, quirks and isolating problems. In small businesses, the same person identifies a business need, makes changes to Magento settings to solve it, and monitors if the change was successful. They know immediately if the change worked as intended. They compare Magento tax settings down to the cent on a single order. They scrutinise the ‘small issues’ that on their own, might seem trivial. But cumulatively, these issues have a big impact on people’s experience using Magento.
Collectively, small merchants are responsible for thousands of small-scale tests of the Magento platform with real store data - every single day. They are the thousands of day-to-day Magento users who help iron out Magento’s quirks and confirm its functionality works as it should.
Small merchants create bug reports, feature suggestions and everything in between help to make Magento stronger. This is valuable feedback which can be used to improve the Magento platform for all users - small, large and Enterprise level merchants, right down to technology partners and solution providers.
Small Merchants Help to Make Extensions Better for Everyone
Small merchants are as real as it gets when it comes to a simple, efficient feedback loop for Magento extensions, themes and integrations.
As an extension developer, small merchants are the best source of feedback and closest connection to our software in actual use that I could ask for. It’s invaluable for improving the features, usability and quality of our extensions.
Working directly with small merchants, I know that requests and feedback come from ‘on the ground’ use and experimentation with Magento. I know that they’re doing a lot of tinkering with the extension and are quick to share the results. Feedback is not being funneled through business analysts or corporate bottlenecks - it’s pretty much instant.
Merchants tend to also be the closest to understanding what new features should be added to each extension. Getting the chance to connect to the actual user of an extension gives me close, realistic feedback that is essential to Fooman continuing to develop high quality extensions that solve real business needs.
Yes, this is nice feedback which helps my business. But well-functioning extensions benefit the entire Magento community, not just extension developers:
- Merchants of all sizes rely on reputable extensions to do more with Magento. Often, Enterprise-level merchants use the very same extensions that also benefit small and mid-sized companies (some big name multi-nationals run Fooman extensions like Pdf Customiser and Picking List)
- Solution providers benefit from being more efficient and cost-effective when they can rely on the right extensions that solve a merchant's need
- Magento benefits when extensions plug gaps in core functionality and provide a staggering number of ‘nice-to-have’ features at an affordable price
Small Merchant Growth Feeds the Magento Ecosystem
Supporting small merchants enables them to grow and scale into bigger e-commerce players. Medium and large sized merchants are not born overnight. They develop over years with a lot of smart people, hard work and encouragement.
Of course, not every small merchant grows to this level. Many, many small merchants will remain one-person operations. They’re able to earn a solid income and support their families using Magento, and that’s pretty cool.
But who knows? I’m willing to bet that some small merchants today will grow to become Magento Enterprise users in the future. I’ve personally witnessed the rapid growth of some standout merchants over the years. In 2009, I first met Graham from Marine Deals. He was working hard to grow his very small company on Magento, and attended our New Zealand Magento Meetup. Fast-forward to now, and he’s running a thriving company with 25,000+ SKU’s sold internationally and a growing team of 26+ staff. Marine Deals placed in the Deloitte Fast 50 business growth awards. It might still be a small business by international standards, but there’s a huge number of Magento developers and extension companies who would love to have Marine Deals as a client.
For those small merchants which grow into bigger players, their growth and success is a catalyst which feeds others in the Magento ecosystem. As the merchant grows they require more support from Magento, technology partners and solution providers. Suddenly, these companies are now in a position to hire a solution provider as they need to invest more in technology and design, or possibly rebuild their DIY site from scratch. They’re competing in a league where upgrading to Magento Enterprise would be a savvy business move. They’re paying your salary as a freelance developer. We all win.
The other thing I’ve noticed from dealing directly with small DIY merchants is the power of the new skillset they’ve acquired - learning to code Magento. I’m aware of a quite a few people who started out running their own Magento stores on the side, have taught themselves to be impressive coders, and have gone on to work as Magento developers. I’d argue that they’re pretty darn good developers too. They’re acutely aware of the business needs of merchants and are in a unique position to deliver on this. Solving Magento problems requires more than just a good coding brain.
How Magento, Technology Providers and Solution Providers Can Support Small Merchants
Now that we’ve established the value that small merchants provide to the Magento ecosystem, it’s time to think about how we can collectively support small merchants as a community.
In order for a merchant to grow and scale to the point where they require the power of Magento Enterprise (and can justify its price tag), they first need support from Magento, technology providers and solution providers. We have the unique opportunity to nurture and connect directly with small merchants.
Instead of constantly hovering over small merchants questioning their platform choice, we should be providing support to them as they tinker, pivot and grow their business.
What can (and should) we be doing? In my view, this would be a good start:
As developers and as a community:
- Respect small merchants’ business decision to build with Magento. Give them a chance and don’t write them off as not being valuable
- Support even the smallest players to get the most out of using Magento at Meetups, local events, forums and Stackexchange. Who knows - your next best marketing tip might come from meeting a small merchant at your local Meetup
- Don’t belittle or underestimate small merchants. Magento position themselves as a platform for trailblazers - but trailblazing is not the exclusive territory of big, well-funded corporates. Small merchants can also be trailblazers - they need to do things differently to get noticed on a budget. They take the Magento platform and push it in creative directions to achieve their marketing goals
If I worked at Magento:
- It’s time to consider small merchant use cases. While they might not be the target audience that brings in the big bucks, they are sure as heck still valuable
- Listen to feedback from small merchants to make the deployment and development process easier for Magento 2. Insights from small merchants will help to make this experience miles better for everyone - including bigger players. It’s a real issue that the Marketplace Web Setup Wizard still doesn’t work - this ongoing Github issue needs serious attention. It might not affect the big boys running Magento 2 Enterprise, but it does affect everyday users of Magento Marketplace, and is not a good look for Magento to attract new customers at any level
- Magento heavyweights like Ben and Sherrie do an awesome job of attending community events, meeting the everyday users of Magento, and facilitating community feedback. This is a great start. But these two very awesome people are just that - two very awesome people. I’d like to see Magento doing more grassroots community outreach and feedback initiatives. Additional effort spent fostering the Magento community will pay itself back and more. It will allow Magento to better serve all customers - larger players and small
I’m curious if you share my view about the small merchants in our Magento community. Share your thoughts in the comments - what should we be doing to help small merchants have a positive experience with Magento?